Peace did not always reign here. In the year 1300, during the First War of Scottish Independence, King Edward the First of England—known as The Hammer of the Scots—took up residence at the abbey after sacking nearby Caerlaverock Castle. His army's presence was devastating; the monks later petitioned for 5,000 pounds in compensation for the burning of their barns and goods, though they likely never received a penny. Even during the Protestant Reformation of 1,560, when monasteries across Scotland were ordered to dissolve, Sweetheart Abbey displayed a unique resilience. Protected by the powerful local Catholic family, the Maxwells, the abbey continued to see mass celebrated by its last monk, Gilbert, until as late as 1,609—long after Catholicism had been officially abolished. This adds a layer of defiance to the abbey’s story, proving that the local community valued these stones far more than the changing political winds in Edinburgh.