The story of this lighthouse is a quintessentially Australian tale of redemption. In 1816, Governor Lachlan Macquarie commissioned the original tower, and he chose an unlikely candidate to design it: a convict named Francis Greenway. Greenway had been transported to Australia for forgery, but his architectural brilliance was undeniable. He warned the Governor that the local sandstone was too soft and would eventually crumble, yet the project moved forward regardless. When it was completed in 1818, the Governor was so impressed by the elegant design that he granted Greenway a full pardon, transforming him from a prisoner to the colony's first civil architect. Interestingly, the first superintendent of the light was Robert Watson, after whom the nearby Watsons Bay is named. Unfortunately, Greenway’s prediction was correct; the poor-quality sandstone began to deteriorate almost immediately, requiring massive iron bands to hold the tower together for decades until it was finally replaced.